Open Pit vs. Underground Mining
Two Ways to Get Rock Out of the Ground
There are two main ways to mine a deposit: dig a large hole from the surface, or tunnel down to reach the metal. The method a company chooses shapes its costs, its risks, and how much of the deposit it can profitably extract.
- Open-pit mining digs down from the surface. Underground mining reaches the deposit through tunnels and shafts.
- The choice depends mainly on how deep the deposit is and how the valuable rock is spread out.
- Open pits are usually cheaper per tonne but move a lot of waste rock. Underground mines cost more but are far more selective.
- The mining method affects a project's costs, safety profile, environmental footprint, and mine life.
- Some mines use both, starting as an open pit and moving underground as they get deeper.
The Simple Difference
Imagine the metal is buried in a hillside. You can scrape away everything above it until you reach it, which is an open pit. Or you can dig a tunnel straight to the metal and leave the rest of the hill in place, which is underground mining. Both approaches get you the metal. They just go about it very differently.
- A large, stepped hole dug down from the surface. Works best when the deposit is near the surface or spread across a wide area.
- Tunnels and shafts that reach the deposit while leaving the surrounding rock in place. Works best when the metal is deep or sits in narrow, high-grade zones.
Open-Pit Mining
In an open-pit mine, the company removes the rock covering the deposit, then digs downward in a series of wide steps called benches, forming a giant bowl. Huge trucks and shovels move enormous volumes of rock.
To reach the ore, miners also have to move rock that contains little or no metal, called waste rock. The relationship between the two is known as the strip ratio, the amount of waste moved for every unit of ore mined.
Beginner Benchmark
What counts as a good strip ratio. A strip ratio compares waste moved with ore mined. A hypothetical 3:1 ratio means three tonnes of waste for each tonne of ore. No single ratio is good for every mine: grade, recovery, metal prices, haul distances and mining costs determine whether the extra waste movement is economic. Compare the life-of-mine ratio with the schedule for each period and check the study’s assumptions.- Usually a lower cost per tonne
- Can mine very large volumes quickly
- Generally simpler and safer to operate
- Can recover a high share of the deposit
- Only works when the deposit is fairly shallow
- Moves large amounts of waste rock
- Larger surface footprint and visual impact
- Costs climb as the pit gets deeper
Underground Mining
In an underground mine, the company digs tunnels or sinks shafts to reach the deposit, then extracts the ore through those passages. Because the mining follows the valuable rock more precisely, underground mines move far less waste.
That precision comes at a cost. Tunnelling is slower and more expensive, requires ventilation and ground support, and is generally more technically demanding and higher-risk than mining from the surface.
- Can reach deep deposits an open pit never could
- Moves far less waste rock
- Smaller surface footprint
- Can selectively target narrow, high-grade zones
- Higher cost per tonne
- Slower to build and to mine
- More complex, with a higher safety risk
- Often recovers a smaller share of the total deposit
Side by Side
| Factor | Open Pit | Underground |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Shallow, wide deposits | Deep or narrow deposits |
| Cost per tonne | Lower | Higher |
| Waste rock moved | A lot | Much less |
| Surface footprint | Larger | Smaller |
| Complexity & risk | Lower | Higher |
Why It Matters to Investors
The mining method is one of the biggest drivers of a project's economics. A shallow, low-cost open pit and a deep, high-cost underground mine can hold the same amount of metal yet be worth very different amounts, simply because their costs and margins differ so much.
When you're reading about a project, it's worth checking:
- Is it open-pit, underground, or a mix of both?
- For open pits, what's the strip ratio, and how deep does the pit go?
- How does the mining method affect cost per tonne and expected margins?
Neither method is better in general. Each suits a different kind of deposit. What matters is whether the chosen method fits the geology and still leaves room for the project to make money.Want more mining news explained this way?
Subscribe to The Mining Watchlist for free mining news and plain-English analysis of what company announcements could mean for investors. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Next in the Mining 101 Series
How to Read Drill Results
Decoding intercepts, grades and widths in a company's news release.
Continue →